Grace suspects Val may have stolen her music box and tries to convince Will that their neighbor is a kleptomaniac. Meanwhile, a gay man trying to go straight tries to convert Jack into a non-practicing homosexual.

Eric McCormack (Will Truman)
Debra Messing (Grace Adler)
Sean Hayes (Jack McFarland)
Megan Mullally (Karen Walker)

Molly Shannon (Val Bassett)
Neil Patrick Harris (Bill)
Marianne Muellerleile (Jodie)
Loren Freeman (Kevin)

Val originally appeared in the 1st season episode "Grace, Replaced".
Val appears to have moved from 15F to 12E (which actually makes more sense, given that 155 Riverside Drive is a 12-story building).
Grace is still dating Josh.
The Christian organization "Focus on Family" objected to this episode, stating that it made a mockery of the struggles of ex-gay men and women.

Transcript of this Episode.

Episode Images:

05/02/2000 09:00 PM: 09.5/14% #40 — *Highest rated NBC show of the evening
07/18/2000 09:00 PM: 08.3/13% #18 — Marathon #4
11/30/2000 09:00 PM: 11.5/16% #19